The Birth Mother Myth

A teenage pregnancy led to an adoption I regretted years later

Photo: Kristina Flour/Unsplash

There were many things I was unprepared for when I relinquished my son for adoption. A naive 17-year-old, I believed the secret I carried would grow lighter, not heavier. I believed the pain of separation would fade. I believed the poster I saw in the adoption agency’s office, proclaiming, “Today is the First Day of the Rest of Your Life” was a harbinger for my new beginning. I would be a college girl, respectable, confident, and happy that my traumatic past was behind me. All of this turned out to be miles from the truth. Still, I plowed through life sometimes doing well, other times not so well, unaware that my biggest post-relinquishment challenge would begin more than a decade later.

When I fell in love with my college boyfriend, he seemed a perfect person to incorporate into my new life. He was undeterred by my confession of my scarlet past. He seemed almost relieved when I told him I didn’t want to have any more children. We were the perfect couple, mostly skipping through life, only occasionally plodding a bit. A dozen years into our marriage, when the ticking of my biological clock synched up with an uptick in our income, we reconsidered our childlessness and had a baby. I was 34 years old when our daughter was born. It had been 16 years since I’d placed my son in the arms of a social worker and walked into a sweltering Iowa summer without him.

I don’t remember anything untoward in the pregnancy with my daughter. I remember happiness, clear skin, and a craving for chocolate milkshakes, in which I regularly indulged. I don’t remember flashing back to my son’s birth as I labored with her. What I remember is that I couldn’t stop marveling about the comfortable hospital birthing center. It was furnished with a rocking chair and a bed instead of a delivery table. My doctor treated me like a human being. My husband was there every minute, and the two of us were served a steak breakfast before we were released the next morning. The birth was straightforward, and our baby was healthy and beautiful.

The Santa Ana winds were tearing through Los Angeles the day the three of us drove home. I’d crocheted a yellow sweater and hat for the baby, complete with a matching blanket. Minutes after I’d dressed her, the nurse instructed me to strip our daughter down to her T-shirt and diaper and sent my husband outside to cool off the car. Stepping out of the air-conditioned hospital lobby into a triple-digit day while clutching a baby who was ramping up to a full-out wail was my passage through the gates of hell.

The baby was still crying when we entered our apartment. I tried putting her to the breast even though my nipples were already sore from the little bit of breastfeeding I’d tried in the hospital. The day spiraled down into pain and tears for both of us. The night was nearly sleepless, and the next morning my husband went to work. That day, and the next, the one after that, and the coming months spiraled downward too. “Wheelchair,” I’d say, mistakenly, when I meant “rocking chair” if I tried to tell anyone how much time I spent rocking in an attempt to comfort the baby. Something was going wrong, and I wasn’t sure how it had begun. My daughter’s face was also my son’s face, the two of them swimming in front of me in a sea of tears.

Each day, rocking and rocking, the unreasonable list of things I was sure of grew.

1. My daughter did not like me. She didn’t trust me. Who could blame her? Why would you trust a woman who’d given away your brother to complete strangers?

2. I was not cut out for motherhood. Look what happened the first time. Now look: I was terrible at it.

3. I should not have given up my son. Why hadn’t anyone explained to me what it was like to hold your baby day after day and have it look into your eyes? Even this baby that didn’t like me was part of me, and I was part of her. I had transgressed life’s most primal bond.

4. My baby would not stop crying because God was punishing me for forsaking my son.

5. My husband did not understand the mother/child bond. He didn’t understand me. He didn’t understand the baby. He didn’t understand anything.

After six weeks of crying and rocking, my siblings, through a series of telephone conversations, perceived that things were not going well and sent our mother out to California to stay with me. My mother was of great comfort. She fixed my breakfast while I sat at the kitchen table and fed the baby. She told me that babies sometimes cry for no reason. She told my husband that, even though he was launching a new law firm, he had to be home no later than 8:00 p.m. All of this motherly intervention improved things somewhat, but still I could not shake the feeling that I was doomed.

I wanted support as I struggled with new motherhood and grief over the loss of my son, but I wasn’t sure where to get it or even what to ask for. Psychology was not the province of small-town Midwesterners, and the only counseling I was familiar with involved sending unruly high schoolers to the guidance counselor’s office. My husband had volunteered for a suicide hotline in college, but my unspoken misery was barely a blip on his preoccupied radar screen. The pediatrician downplayed my anxieties about the baby. She had colic. That was all it was, and there wasn’t much to be done. Friends were kind and caring, but most of them didn’t have children — and even those that did were unaware of my secret past. Any personal resources I should have been able to muster were nowhere to be found. Grief welled up each day, and each day I swallowed it down.

I told her I’d had a baby that I’d given up for adoption, “But,” I said, “I’m over that, and I don’t need to talk about it.”

It was seven months before I made it out the door to a La Leche League meeting. Finally, I was in the company of other mothers who felt they needed support too, albeit over breastfeeding, but at least I had one morning a month where I could tell other women I wasn’t feeling optimistic. Some weeks after that, I arranged for a mother I’d met in the group to babysit while I went to see a psychologist.

I could barely talk at the psychologist appointment. Overwhelmed with discomfort, I was suspicious of her and the paperwork she’d had me fill out. She asked me if I had anything to add to the information on the forms. I told her I’d had a baby that I’d given up for adoption, “But,” I said, “I’m over that, and I don’t need to talk about it.” She believed me. Or maybe she didn’t — in any case, she moved on. Instead, we discussed how overwhelmed I felt at being a mother. “Do you feel that you might be a danger to your daughter?” she asked. Sick with terror that she might have my baby taken from me, I assured her that I would never harm her, all the while wishing I were dead. The next week, I canceled the follow-up appointment.

With the friendships I made in La Leche League, there were opportunities for playdates, playgroups, birthday parties, and outings. Time brought some of the comfort I sought even if a dark voice inside me couldn’t help wondering if my daughter’s shyness, her tantrums, her somewhat late developmental milestones were my fault.

When my daughter was three and a half I had another little girl, and I began to grieve for my son all over again. This time my mother and my aunt were there from the beginning. They made their plans to visit the moment I told them I was pregnant. As I recall, the conversation involved an anecdote about some relative who’d put her baby into a pot on the stove and might have cooked her if the husband hadn’t saved the day. My mother, who was still working, spent her entire two-week vacation with me. My aunt, who was retired, stayed for an additional month. While we did not once discuss my secret teenage pregnancy or the ensuing adoption, at least I was never alone.

When my younger daughter was about a year old, I sat at a picnic table in the park with a friend from La Leche League. As we sat nursing our girls, her eyes filled with tears, and she told me she given up her first child — another daughter — for adoption. She told me she thought of her constantly and that she was going to search for her. I went with her to a Concerned United Birthparents meeting, and even though I was told there was no hope of finding any information in Iowa that might lead me to my son, I decided I’d search for him anyway.

By the end of that year, through a cloak-and-dagger intrigue that involved a large sum of cash in a plain brown envelope, I learned my son’s name and contacted him. We were reunited while my daughters were still young enough that they don’t remember not having a brother. Now into my third decade of reunion with my son, it’s my daughters’ lack of loss for which I am most grateful. I still suffer pangs of guilt over my older daughter’s early years and the compromised mother I was, but she and her sister know their brother. They know his wife. They know their nieces and their nephew. And I know that everything I was told as a 17-year-old handing over her newborn was a lie.

Originally published in Portrait of an Adoption, a feature of

Birth/first mother, recovering wife, retired caregiver, traveler. Advocate of #adopteerights and #reproductiverights. Subscribe at

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store